Skip to main content

Comandante C40 MK4 vs Comandante C40 MK5

Comprehensive Technical Comparison

The Verdict

Both generations share the same basics: 39mm Nitro Blade conical burrs, stepped adjustment at roughly 30 microns per click, a single-dose workflow, 550 g weight and a 40g capacity, aimed at filter brewing and travel. Both reviews treat espresso as a weak spot and note no anti-static treatment. The MK4 is $250-$300 and the MK5 is $280-$330. The specs list updated Nitro Blade burrs and improved uniformity as MK5 strengths, and the MK5 grind quality score is 9.0 against 8.8.

The MK5 also scores higher overall (8.4 to 8.2) and on ease of use (7.5 to 7.0). The MK4 scores higher on build (9.0 to 8.5) and value (7.0 to 6.5). The published specs and reviews do not list every change between the two. Beyond the burr and uniformity note, the reviews describe different catch jars: the MK4 switched from glass to a tougher plastic jar, while the MK5 review describes a glass jar it calls inert and easy to clean but fragile. The scores are close on every measure.

Choose the MK4 if you want the same Comandante basics for around $30 less and care more about build and value scores.

Read the Comandante C40 MK4 review →

Choose the MK5 if you want the updated burrs and slightly better scores for grind quality and ease of use, and accept the higher price.

Read the Comandante C40 MK5 review →

Updated

Comandante C40 MK4
Comandante C40 MK4
Comandante C40 MK5
Comandante C40 MK5
Grinder Type
manual
manual
Burr Shape
conical
conical
Burr Size
39mm
39mm
Burr Material
steel
steel
Adjustment
Stepped
Stepped
Resolution
30μm
30μm
Price Tier
$250-$300
$280–$330
Key Strengths
Comandante C40 MK4
  • ✓ Exceptional consistency
  • ✓ Nitro Blade burrs
  • ✓ Built for decades
Comandante C40 MK5
  • ✓ Updated Nitro Blade burrs
  • ✓ Legendary build quality
  • ✓ Improved uniformity
Trade-offs
Comandante C40 MK4
  • ✗ Premium price
  • ✗ Click adjustment only
Comandante C40 MK5
  • ✗ Premium price
  • ✗ Click adjustment only
  • ✗ Strictly for filter purists

"Choosing the right grinder depends on your specific workflow. Both the Comandante C40 MK4 and Comandante C40 MK5 are capable machines, but their technical characteristics favor different brewing styles."

Try Another Battle →